5050 Fifty Fifty Politics ← Go to Homepage
Criminal Justice

U.S. Executions Nearly Doubled in 2025. Public Support Hit a 50-Year Low.

Fifty Fifty Politics · Background & Data
Two numbers moved in opposite directions in 2025: executions surged to their highest level in over 16 years, while public support for the death penalty fell to a 50-year low. This piece lays out the real data behind that disconnect, and where capital punishment actually stands state by state.

Executions nearly doubled in 2025, driven almost entirely by one state

Executions rose sharply from 25 in 2024 to 47 in 2025, according to the Death Penalty Information Center's year-end report, ending roughly a decade of historically low execution numbers and reaching the highest annual total in over 16 years. This surge was driven almost entirely by a single state: Florida alone carried out 19 executions in 2025, accounting for 40% of the national total by itself.

Ten military veterans were executed in 2025, seven of them in Florida, the highest number of veterans executed in nearly 20 years according to DPIC's analysis. All 47 executions in 2025 involved male defendants; the methods included lethal injection, nitrogen hypoxia, and firing squad, reflecting states' continued search for execution methods as lethal injection drugs have grown harder for states to source.

U.S. Executions: 2024 vs. 2025 — Source: Death Penalty Information Center, year-end report, 2025. U.S. Executions: 2024 vs. 2025 25 2024 47 2025 (19 in Florida alone)
Source: Death Penalty Information Center, year-end report, 2025.

Meanwhile, the death row population and public support are both at multi-decade lows

Despite the 2025 execution surge, the actual death row population has declined for 24 consecutive years, down to approximately 2,004 inmates nationally, the lowest figure in over 32 years, according to Death Penalty Information Center data. This reflects a longer-term decline in new death sentences being imposed by juries, even as the pace of executions for existing death row inmates increased sharply in 2025.

Public opinion has moved in the same declining direction over a much longer timeframe. Gallup polling shows support for the death penalty for convicted murderers fell to 52% in 2025, a 50-year low, down from 76% in 1991. Opposition simultaneously reached its highest recorded level at 44%. This creates a genuine disconnect: today's executions are largely carrying out sentences imposed decades ago, when public support exceeded 70%, meaning the executions happening now reflect a very different public mood than the one that produced the original sentences.

Public Support for the Death Penalty, 1991 vs. Today — Source: Gallup polling, 1991 and 2025. Public Support for the Death Penalty, 1991 vs. Today 76% 1991 52% Today (50-year low)
Source: Gallup polling, 1991 and 2025.

Where the death penalty currently stands, state by state

A specific, less-discussed dimension: mental illness and childhood trauma

Documented serious mental illness, including schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, appears in numerous executed individuals' case histories, yet the Supreme Court has not categorically barred execution of people with serious mental illness (as distinct from intellectual disability, which the Court has separately restricted). Severe childhood trauma, including documented physical abuse, sexual abuse, and neglect, is described as nearly universal among death row populations in research compiled from Department of Justice data, but juries focused on the specifics of the crime itself often don't weigh this history heavily in sentencing, according to this research.

The core disagreement

Supporters of capital punishment generally argue it provides appropriate retribution for the most severe crimes and can serve as a deterrent, and that the legal process, extensive appeals, and executive clemency review already provide substantial safeguards against wrongful execution. Opponents generally cite the documented mental illness and trauma histories common among death row populations, the cost and length of the appeals process itself, and continued innocence claims as reasons capital punishment is applied inconsistently and irreversibly. The genuine, less-discussed empirical question beneath the debate is the widening gap between falling public support and the recent surge in executions, both sides can point to real data supporting their read of where the country's mood actually stands, since declining new death sentences and declining overall support coexist with the sharpest single-year execution increase in over a decade.

Want the core arguments from both sides, side by side?

See the Left vs. Right Breakdown on Death Penalty →
Sources
Browse All Blogs